Reviews
They need to do better
Not handicap friendly- handicap assessable room had a dip in the floor to the bathroom requiring lifting a wheelchair, a non ADA low toilet and no automatic doors at the entrance.
Never Again
BAIT & SWITCH We went to breakfast on a Sunday morning in the hotel restaurant, after being told the day before that we can order from the menu. When we got there sat down and they brought us our coffee, we were told it’s buffet only on the weekend. $30 per person. We are in our late 80s. We dont eat big breakfasts, much less a buffet We traveled in from Florida and didn’t have any transportation to go to a local restaurant. They wouldn’t accommodate us so I was intimidated into paying the buffet price for two eggs and a piece of toast each. When I wrote to Hyatt corporate asking for a credit because it was misrepresentation by your staff, and it’s also a “gotcha” that they allow you to order from the menu during the week, but not on the weekends, which I only found out on Sunday when I was already sitting at the table with a cup of coffee. I wrote to corporate asking for a $65 credit, and they offered me Hyatt points like I’m gonna comeback there…. not a chance!
General Manager, Agency / Consultant at Hyatt Regency Long Island, responded to this review
We’re sorry that the weekend breakfast options and pricing did not meet your expectations. We recognize that the buffet format was not suited to your dining preferences, particularly given your limited transportation options. We’ve also noted your disappointment with the resolution offered by Hyatt corporate. We regret that this experience left you with a negative impression. Everything we do is aimed at providing every guest with an excellent experience. We would like to regain your trust and hope you will give us that opportunity in the future.
Very expensive and not worth the money
For the price they charge I recommend the residence inn down the street. The walls at the Hyatt were so thin we thought one of our phones was playing music but it was the room next door who had quiet music on but you can hear it clear as day. The elevators were not working well because of renovations. We used the freight elevator once as suggested by staff but didn’t use it again once we had to move carts of half eaten food and soiled linens to to get to the elevator. I paid over $400 for one night. I wanted to stay the Fridays before there with my daughter’s team but they wanted to charge 1700.00 for one night for one room. We opted to stay down the street at the residence inn which was amazing, super clean and cozy. I paid 230.00 there and it was well worth it. The Hyatt was super crowded, people weee smoking pot right outside of the entrance to the hotel. It was just not the experience you would think you would get for the price of the stay. In the bathroom there was a piece of wall paper that was plastered on a spot they were trying to cover. It looked like a toddler glued it on. They should have just replaced the wall paper on that small section of the bathroom. It looked terrible. I would for sure choose a different location if you are choosing to stay on that part of the island. I’ve stayed at the holiday inn in the area that I would have much rather stayed at then this Hyatt again.
General Manager, Agency / Consultant at Hyatt Regency Long Island, responded to this review
We’re sorry that the noise from neighboring rooms and the elevator delays affected your stay. We’ve also taken note of your comments about the condition of the bathroom and the experience in the common areas. We recognize that these details can shape a guest’s overall impression, especially during a short visit. Thank you for sharing your concerns and giving us the opportunity to better understand your experience.
Disappointing stay. Dors not live up to its brand
We recently stayed three nights at the Hyatt Regency Long Island while attending a family wedding. Unfortunately, the hotel fell well below our expectations for a Hyatt Regency property. The guest rooms were dated, the main elevators were out of service, requiring guests to use service elevators, and the ice machines were not functioning. Guests had to collect bags of ice themselves. Most concerning was a reservation mix-up. Despite having a printed confirmation for four nights, I received a message indicating I was checking out early. After a lengthy consultation with management, the front desk clerk returned and announced, “We’re going to let you stay,” without offering any explanation for the error! The hotel had notified us about the elevator situation shortly before arrival, but apparently these problems had been ongoing. On the positive side, we received a very reasonable military rate of $142 per night, and the hotel provided convenient transportation to the wedding reception. Nevertheless, this property needs significant updating and better management. **Not the quality or service I would expect from the Hyatt Regency name.**
General Manager, Agency / Consultant at Hyatt Regency Long Island, responded to this review
We’re sorry to learn that aspects of your visit did not leave the impression you had anticipated. We recognize that unexpected changes and uncertainty during a stay can be frustrating. As your reservation was arranged through an online travel agency, their customer service team would be best positioned to assist with any booking-related questions, as they have direct access to your reservation details. On a positive note, we’re glad the special rate offered good value and that the transportation provided for the wedding was helpful. We hope to have another opportunity to welcome you back.
Maintenance problems; understaffed hotel
Hyatt informed us days before our stay their elevators were broken and slow and were making the maintenance elevators available. I asked if we should be concerned since this was our wedding weekend. They said staff would be around to direct us to service elevators and they'd have someone managing the service elevators. I didn't see a single staff member assigned to the elevators. Overall they seemed overstaffed and gave me an email with the tone "sorry about the elevators, you'll just have to deal with them." They knew it was my wedding weekend and didn't write us a note or anything. The MORNING OF our wedding, 3 hours deep into hair and makeup and needing to go to our preshoot, the hotel has a fire alarm evacuation because of their dumb elevators, making us late and stressed. Hyatt has not acknowledged this at all or offered any form of compensation for their maintenance problems.
General Manager, Agency / Consultant at Hyatt Regency Long Island, responded to this review
We regret that your wedding weekend was affected by the elevator difficulties and the unexpected fire alarm. We recognize that these disruptions were especially disappointing during such an important occasion. We’re also sorry that the communication and assistance you experienced did not meet your expectations. We hope to have an opportunity to provide a more positive experience in the future.
Host Your Wedding Events Anywhere Else
Do not host your wedding events here. Literally anywhere else on Long Island would be a better option. My family and I reserved a block of rooms for my sister's wedding this past weekend. In addition to this, we booked a getting ready room for the morning of my sister's wedding and a post nuptial brunch the day after. The morning of my sister's wedding, we reserved a getting ready room to have hair and makeup done. This room was reserved to be open at 7AM and hair and makeup artists were due to arrive by 8:15. When I arrived with the bridesmaids to enter the room and get everything set up for the hair and makeup artists (At 8, when the room should've already been open for an hour), every door to the room we reserved was locked. Seeing this as no big deal, I went to the front desk to inform them that the room we reserved was locked and asked if someone could please open the doors. The girls behind the desk were dismissive and said that they would try to contact the engineer. I went back to the hallway outside of the room to wait for the arrival of whoever could open the door. After about 10 minutes of waiting, the hair and makeup artists arrived, and I went to the desk again. The same girls were playing on their phones and told me that they "contacted the engineer" but there was "nothing that they can do". Now, you would think at a Hyatt Regency hotel that is (allegedly) a 4 star location that someone behind the front desk could do something as simple as open a door my family paid hundreds of dollar to reserve. However, it seems that these simple expectations were too much for this location. After returning to wait for another 5 minutes, I AGAIN went to the front desk. They again said that there was really "nothing they could do" and that we "had to wait". This is when I finally witnessed them pick up a phone and call someone. When the engineer arrived to the room after another 5 minutes, he apologized and said that he was just called to open the door. The front desk had not called anyone for help until they were harassed 3 different times. We are now finally in a room we were supposed to have for an hour and a half beforehand and thirty minutes behind schedule. When the room was entered, the water station that was included in the room as well as the pastry breakfast that my sister had asked for and discussed with her contractor back in May, was not there. My sister and I again went to the front desk. The same women told me that my sister did not pay for the breakfast, even though the SAME PERSON I WAS SPEAKING WITH confirmed IN PERSON with my sister two days before that it would be there. At this point, they sent someone by with the alleged contracts (after having me wait around in the lobby for 15 minutes for the person and finally telling them to send her by the room). This was not the same person my sister signed her contracts with and had no knowledge of anything my sister had booked. She was however the most helpful person we dealt with and made sure that we eventually had the water station (that was supposed to come with the room no matter what) as well as the breakfast delivered. The unnecessary stress this caused my sister the morning of her wedding was completely unacceptable. The so called customer service was abysmal and I truly have never felt more dismissed in my life over a matter that should have been easily handled. If you are planning on getting married on Long Island and need a hotel for a room block or to get ready in, I would highly recommend you look elsewhere. I know that I will be telling every bride I know to do the same.
General Manager, Agency / Consultant at Hyatt Regency Long Island, responded to this review
We regret that the arrangements for your sister’s wedding morning did not go as anticipated. We recognize how important it is for wedding preparations to run smoothly, and delays in accessing the reserved room added unnecessary pressure to an already special day. We also acknowledge the confusion surrounding the breakfast and water service. While we’re glad a team member was able to assist, we regret that the overall coordination and communication fell short of your expectations. Once again, we apologize for the difficulties you encountered and hope you’ll consider a return visit so we can provide a more enjoyable experience.
Fall getaway
Great service! Parking ,restaurant,large room Dining and lobby were updated. Pool and gym were a plus. Convenient to golf course
General Manager, Agency / Consultant at Hyatt Regency Long Island, responded to this review
We’re glad our team helped make your getaway enjoyable. It’s nice to know you appreciated the spacious room and refreshed dining and lobby areas. Having the pool and fitness center available added to your stay, and our location made it convenient to enjoy a round of golf. We look forward to welcoming you back for another relaxing visit!
Nice but filthy common areas in am
Beautiful hotel except filthy common areas in the mornings They don't clean when bar closes& leave the filth until maintenance comes in at 7am which is a problem because all the tvs tables etc are in filth I was stuck in a room by checking or to sit in filth Not what I paid for If this was motel 6 prices maybe ok
Very Disappointed
I was promised a 1st floor room and then when I arrived they said they don't even have rooms on the 1st floor. also not having blankets on the bed just sheets and then when I requested blankets i was brought thin little blankets. I never stayed in a hotel that doesn't have blankets on the bed. The bed and pillows were so uncomfortable. They were both hard as a rock. and you don't even have a little coffee maker in the room. I will never stay in a Hyatt again.
Elevators don't work
The elevators don't work. They haven't worked for the 3 years I have had to stay at this hotel for business meetings. Each time I have been told they were on the verge of being fixed and they have never been fixed. We all took the service elevators and bonded with other hotel guests over how low rent it was. Rooms otherwise clean. Very few amenities and no free water bottles.
Hyatt Regency Long Island is Superb
If having a comfortable, safe and beautifully furnished hotel is important to you, the Hyatt Regency Long Island will exceed your expectations. Staff like Lilly, Chalese and management like Annamarie and Sabrina go above and beyond in customer service. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay as we have in the numerous past stays. We are always amazed. Thanks Hyatt and the incredible staff. The hotel is tops.
Not great
Elevators are broken. Incredibly loud with the various events they have going on. $500/night is a joke for this place. Be better
Needs updating!
Main elevators were broken and have been for months. Only 1 service elevator was working for entire hotel. Had to use stairs most of the time to get up and down. Rooms were outdated. Rugs were old and gross. Showers were old and did not work great. Some family members had showers that didn’t even work and were told no one would be there to fix it until Sunday. We were there Thursday & Friday.
AVOID this hotel if you can!
Major repairs in progress. Multiple weddings and, at most, 2 functioning elevators (one of which was freight, the other with a posted max of 6 passengers). 9+ floors, people in wheelchairs, luggage carts, for whom stairs weren’t an option. Rooms are clean, reasonably quiet/well laid out, but rundown. Bed was comfortable. A/C was distractingly loud @ night. Free Parking was nice, sufficient.
Great Hotel in Long island
Excellent Service, front desk. Room service and breakfast food and service was great. Gym has impoved but still needs work.
No elevator ride for you!!
Overall the hotel was nice. There was a problem with the elevators not working. This looks like it has been an on going problem. They are trying to fix. The hotel was full at the time of our stay. I’m sure this added to the issue. Long wait times. And the one service elevator was always full. People were using the stairs it’s a 10 story building. Have fun carrying your luggage.
Not worth the Hyatt Name
The passenger elevators were not working, and only one dirty freight elevator. We were there for a wedding. There were 4 other weddings staying at this hotel. The freight elevator was dirty and you had to wait to get into one because it was always crowded. The bar is small and drinks expensive. 1 Prosecco and 1 Beer was $39.15 before tip. Breakfast buffet was $30 and the food was good. You were able to get a freshly cooked omlet with the other items on the buffet bar.
Elevator chaos overshadows great potential
The location was great and the staff was very friendly. We had both a dinner in the hotel one night as well as breakfast both mornings we were there and all of it was delicious ! The bartender in the lobby bar was excellent and made the 1.5 hour wait to check in (first red flag) almost tolerable. The staff at breakfast was attentive, personable, and professional. We all really enjoyed the quality of the breakfast! The sad part is that though the staff themselves were pleasant and professional, the elevator situation was a complete trainwreck...worse was finding out that this is somewhat typical by those that have to frequent this hotel. At one point, only one elevator worked for the entire building and it was the service elevator.... waiting for one took forever and was such a dissappointment when it finally got to your floor and saw it was filled with people. Our friends missed the shuttle to the wedding venue and had to get an Uber because they spent so much time trying to catch an elevator from the 7th floor. Because we were there for a wedding, we had a lot of friends and family on different floors and it made it a logistical nightmare to go to different rooms/functions/meals.
Remarkable hosts!
Excellent hotel that has incredible ability to manage so many events while making each one feel unique. Next summer i get my turn to be hosting wedding versus attending and can only hope this continues! I have no doubt.
Hyatt or Motel? At This Point, I’m Not Sure
If you would like to sweat in your room, never have enough towels, and spend your stay making multiple trips up and down the stairs, using a service elevator, or waiting 10–15 minutes for the only functioning guest elevator, then this is the hotel for you! Check-in was actually amazing—friendly, efficient, and a great start to our stay. Unfortunately, it went dramatically downhill from there. There were FIVE weddings taking place at the hotel that weekend, yet somehow only ONE guest elevator was operational. The wait was routinely 10–15 minutes, and when it finally arrived, everyone was packed in like sardines. There also weren’t enough luggage carts available, which meant multiple trips up and down just to get our belongings to and from the room. With a hotel operating at this level of occupancy, I cannot understand how this was considered acceptable. Then there was our room. The AC was not working properly, so the room was unbearably warm. Even more frustrating, after housekeeping cleaned the room, we would come back to find that the temperature had been turned UP. We also repeatedly did not have enough towels. Checkout was the final straw. By the time I left, I was absolutely DRENCHED—and no, it wasn’t from the monsoon happening outside. Because there were no luggage carts available, I once again had to make multiple trips. On one elevator ride from the 5th floor, I somehow ended up traveling all the way to the 10th floor before coming back down, stopping at nearly every floor along the way while crammed into an overcrowded elevator. What should have been a simple checkout process became an ordeal. Thank God we weren’t actually at the hotel very much during our stay, because spending any significant amount of time there would have been miserable. And if all of that wasn’t enough, we had dinner at the hotel’s bar one evening only to discover that they were OUT OF FOOD. At a hotel hosting five weddings. At that point, what else could you do but laugh? So my recommendation: come prepared to rough it like you’re backpacking through Europe—although, frankly, backpacking through Europe probably would have been more enjoyable than this “experience.” I’ve stayed at Hyatt properties before, which is exactly why this was so disappointing. This is nowhere near the standard I associate with Hyatt. The entire experience felt more like staying at a poorly managed motel than a Hyatt property. This was easily the worst experience I have ever had at a Hyatt. If this had been my first Hyatt stay, I genuinely would never consider staying at one again. Extremely disappointed.
Showing 20 reviews since September 18, 2026.